Andrew Carnegie and the story of US Steel

By Michalis Voutsinas


In the mid-1800s, steamboats dominated the riverways. All traffic to and from St. Louis relied on steamboats for transportation across the river. Cargo from the railroads was transferred onto steamboats, ferried across the river, and then loaded onto another train for continued transport. The formidable width and swift currents of the Mississippi River presented immense obstacles to aspiring bridge builders, compounded by political and economic resistance from the steamboat industry. However, James Buchanan Eads possessed both a profound skepticism of riverboats and an unwavering determination. This unique combination of traits was essential in overcoming the seemingly insurmountable challenges to construct the bridge deemed impossible by many.

The Eads Bridge stands as a testament to engineering ingenuity, boasting a distinctive three-arch steel truss design. Its completion in 1874 marked a watershed moment in bridge construction—it was not only the largest bridge of its era but also the first to utilize steel, offering the sole means for trains to traverse the mighty Mississippi River. This monumental achievement represented a profound technological leap forward, heralding a new era in large-scale steel construction.

The project encountered numerous setbacks, with financial challenges threatening its progress on multiple occasions. Yet, it was the relentless entrepreneurial spirit and unwavering determination of Andrew Carnegie that proved pivotal in securing much-needed investor capital during critical junctures. Despite facing near-failure scenarios, Carnegie's perseverance ensured that the project persevered, ultimately culminating in the completion of the bridge after seven years of arduous labor.

And yet, skepticism loomed large among the populace. During that era, one out of every four bridges succumbed to failure, plunging trains, passengers, and cargo into treacherous waters below. But, Andrew Carnegie remained undeterred by doubt, possessing both courage and unwavering confidence in his bridge's stability. Drawing inspiration from an anecdote suggesting that elephants, due to their innate instincts, refused to traverse unstable foundations, Carnegie pressed forward.

On the day of the bridge's grand opening, a curious public gathered to witness the unfolding spectacle. Leading a parade across the bridge, Andrew Carnegie stood alongside a circus elephant, symbolizing his faith in the bridge's structural integrity. As the majestic creature traversed the span with assured steps, never faltering, the gathered crowd watched in awe. Inspired by the elephant's unwavering stride, the people followed suit, emboldened by Carnegie's audacity. In this symbolic moment, Andrew Carnegie not only achieved his goal of constructing a formidable bridge but also vindicated his reputation, proving the naysayers wrong and ushering in a new era of confidence in engineering prowess.

In 1860, the United States had a modest steel production of only 13,000 tonnes. By 1880, this figure skyrocketed to 1,467,000 tonnes, showcasing a remarkable surge in industrial capacity. Just two decades later, in 1900, the nation's steel output reached a staggering 11,227,000 tonnes – exceeding the combined production of England and Germany. During this transformative period, steel emerged as the definitive yardstick for measuring a country's industrial prowess, with Andrew Carnegie emerging as a central figure responsible for America's ascendancy in steel production. Through strategic acquisitions and vertical integration,

Carnegie Steel systematically acquired its sources of raw materials and transportation infrastructure, while also absorbing and consolidating its competitors. This aggressive expansion allowed Carnegie Steel to assert dominance over the steel industry, solidifying its position as the largest and most profitable steel company globally by the 1890s.

In 1901, Andrew Carnegie, then aged 65 and considering retirement, made the pivotal decision to divest himself of the Carnegie Steel Company. Commencing negotiations in February and March of that year, Carnegie engaged in talks with a consortium led by the prominent American financier J.P. Morgan. After deliberations, they reached an agreement on the sale of the company for an astounding $480 million. Through the amalgamation of numerous steel enterprises, this transaction facilitated the creation of US Steel, capitalized at an unprecedented $1.4 billion. In doing so, US Steel etched its name in the annals of history as the first billion-dollar corporation in American history.

In the subsequent years, US Steel's significance in the global steel industry gradually receded as it encountered stiff competition from emerging Asian producers. Over the course of several decades, Asian manufacturers rose to prominence, reshaping the industry's dynamics. According to the World Steel Association, global crude steel production reached 1.85 billion tonnes in 2023. While overall production for the 71 countries reporting to worldsteel experienced a marginal decline of 0.1 percent compared to the previous year, notable trends emerged. China, maintaining its status as the world's leading steel producer, sustained stable production levels, reaching 1 billion tonnes in 2023. Meanwhile, India, the second-largest global steel producer, exhibited robust growth with a production increase of 11.8 percent, reaching 140.2 million tonnes. Conversely, Japan, historically a major steel producer, witnessed a decline in production, dropping by 2.5 percent to 87 million tonnes in 2023. Similarly, the United States reported a marginal increase in steel production, reaching 87 million tonnes, representing a modest rise of 0.2 percent compared to the preceding year.

One and a half centuries after the historic moment when an elephant first stepped onto the Eads Bridge, US Steel Corp. finds itself the subject of acquisition interest amid a series of challenges. Nippon Steel Corp. has expressed its firm commitment to finalizing its $14.1 billion acquisition of United States Steel Corp. Following President Joe Biden's statement advocating for the company to remain under US ownership, Japan's largest steel company reiterated its previous offer, pledging an additional $1.4 billion in investment. The deal aims to strengthen the company's position in the growing U.S. market amid declining demand for steel products in Japan and the growing importance of electric vehicles. Moreover, Nippon Steel Corp. assured that there would be no layoffs or plant closures until at least September 2026, as stated in a press release on Friday.

While Capesizes remain vigilant regarding the intricate interplay of politics, geopolitics, economics, and finance surrounding the Nippon Steel-US Steel deal, Panamaxes continue their journey northward for yet another week. Their consistent movement contributes to the ongoing upward trajectory of the Baltic Dry Index, which surged today to approximately 2374 points.

Data source: Doric